Request a free estimate Call (586) 722-3277

Older Homes · 7 min read

How to Tell Plaster From Drywall Before You Paint or Repair

A few minutes of looking and tapping tells you what your walls are made of, and that decides how they should be patched, primed and painted.

Tap the wall with a knuckle: plaster feels hard and cool and gives a dull, solid sound, while drywall sounds lighter and slightly hollow between the studs. Then look at the cut edge of the wall around an outlet box, and along the wall in low, side light. Together, those checks answer the question for most rooms without damaging anything.

Key takeaways

  • Plaster sounds solid and feels cool and hard when tapped; drywall sounds lighter and a little hollow between studs.
  • Raking light shows drywall’s taped seams and plaster’s gentle waves, and the cut edge of the wall around an outlet box shows its thickness.
  • Many Grosse Pointe homes mix both, because additions, remodeled kitchens and finished basements often use drywall.
  • Knowing the material first changes the patch compound, the primer and the way cracks are handled.
Jump to a section
  1. Why does it matter whether a wall is plaster or drywall?
  2. How do plaster and drywall compare at a glance?
  3. What does the tap test tell you?
  4. What does raking light show?
  5. What can switch plates, corners and openings tell you?
  6. Do Grosse Pointe homes have both plaster and drywall?
  7. How does the material change repair and painting?
  8. What if you still cannot tell which it is?
  9. Questions

Why does it matter whether a wall is plaster or drywall?

Because the two materials fail in different ways and are repaired in different ways. A paint job that treats plaster like drywall, or the reverse, often shows it sooner or later as a crack that returns, a patch that dulls, or a ridge that catches the light.

Plaster is a hard, mineral surface troweled on in coats over wood strips called lath, metal lath or masonry. It is heavy, dense and often a little wavy. Drywall is paper-faced gypsum board screwed to the studs, with taped seams covered in joint compound. It is flatter and lighter, but its seams, fasteners and paper facing need their own care.

The choice of patch material, primer, sheen and even the order of work depends on which one is under the paint.

How do plaster and drywall compare at a glance?

CheckPlasterDrywall
Tap soundDense and dull, little echoLighter, hollow between studs
Raking lightGentle waves, no seam patternFlat, with taped seams and fastener heads
Thickness and feelThicker, heavy, hard and coolAbout ½ inch, lighter, dents easily
Seams and cornersNo seams; corners often softenedTaped seams; crisp corners
Typical cracksHairlines at openings; bulges if looseCracks along taped seams; nail pops
Repair approachFasten loose areas, fill, feather into the wavesReset fasteners, finish the joint

What does the tap test tell you?

Rap lightly with a knuckle at several spots, moving across the wall at about chest height. Plaster answers with a dense, dull “tock” and almost no echo; drywall gives a lighter, hollower “thup” between studs and a firmer sound right over a stud.

A hollow, drummy sound in a plaster wall is a separate finding: it can mean the plaster has let go of its lath and needs attention before painting. Our guide to loose plaster repair explains what that looks like and what the fix involves. Keep the taps gentle, since separated plaster can crumble if struck hard and drywall dents easily.

What does raking light show?

Turn off the room lights, then shine a bright flashlight or a phone light almost flat against the wall from a few feet away. This low, side-on light is called raking light, and it exaggerates every surface variation.

Drywall often shows long, straight, slightly raised bands where seams were taped, a regular grid of screw or nail heads, and a very even surface between them. Plaster shows gentle undulations and trowel sweeps, especially around door casings and in corners, with no seam pattern (an old patch can show as a faint rectangle).

Whatever shows in raking light will still show under new paint, only less so in a flat finish, which is why uneven plaster is often painted flat or matte. See our paint sheen guide.

Painting rooms like this in Grosse Pointe?

Tell us about your home and we’ll be in touch to talk it through.

Request a free estimate

What can switch plates, corners and openings tell you?

These spots show a wall’s thickness and construction without cutting anything.

  1. Switch plate and outlet edges. Switch the circuit off at the breaker, then confirm it is dead with a non-contact voltage tester before you remove a cover plate. With the plate off, the cut edge of the wall around the box often shows its thickness. Drywall is commonly about half an inch thick, sometimes five-eighths. The National Park Service’s Preservation Brief 21 on repairing historic flat plaster gives minimum plaster thicknesses of about ½ inch over rock lath, ⅝ inch over metal lath and ¾ to ⅞ inch over wood lath. Add the lath behind it, and plaster over lath is typically noticeably thicker; you may also see a rough, darker base coat under a thin white finish coat.
  2. Corners and openings. Outside corners and archways in plaster are often slightly rounded or softened by hand, while drywall corners are usually crisp, often with a metal or vinyl bead. Rounded corners are a hint, not proof, since some drywall rooms were finished with them too.
  3. Open wall cavities and attic hatches. Where the back of a wall or ceiling can be seen, such as an opened wall cavity or the top of a ceiling viewed from an attic hatch (look from the hatch and never step between the joists), plaster shows lumps called keys squeezed between wood strips, while drywall shows the plain paper back of the board.

Do not poke around inside an electrical box with tools. If you are not comfortable removing a cover plate, skip it. The tap test and raking light are enough for most walls.

Do Grosse Pointe homes have both plaster and drywall?

Often. Many houses in Grosse Pointe and across Metro Detroit were built in the 1920s through the 1940s, when plaster over lath was a common wall construction; Preservation Brief 21 notes that plaster was the wall surface chosen for nearly all buildings until the 1930s or 40s. Some of those homes have since gained an addition, a remodeled kitchen or bath, or a finished attic or basement, and those spaces are commonly drywall.

Post-war Colonials, Capes and ranches may be drywall, plaster or a mix, depending on the builder and the year. Our guides to 1920s Tudor interiors and mid-century ranch interiors show how that plays out in each era.

That means the answer can change from room to room, even from one wall to another. A patched ceiling in a plaster house may be drywall, and a plaster wall may be hidden behind paneling or wallpaper, so check the wall where each problem is, not just the one nearest the door.

How does the material change repair and painting?

A careful painter adjusts the work to the surface.

  • Safety. Paint in a pre-1978 home may contain lead, and older plasters, joint compounds and textured finishes may contain asbestos. The EPA’s homeowner page on protecting your family from exposures to asbestos says you generally cannot tell by looking whether a material contains it, that you may want a trained and accredited professional to inspect before remodeling, that a professional should take any samples, and that sanding, scraping, drilling or cutting may release fibers. If asbestos turns up, leave it undisturbed and ask a qualified asbestos professional whether to leave it, seal it or remove it; do not scrape or sand it yourself. For lead dust, wet-wipe surfaces and use a HEPA-filter vacuum, not an ordinary vacuum or dry sweeping. The EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) rule requires certified firms and lead-safe work practices for paid work that generally disturbs more than 6 square feet of painted surface per room inside a pre-1978 home. Our guide to lead paint in older homes explains more.
  • Patching. Small holes and hairline cracks in plaster are typically filled with a compound suited to plaster, sanded smooth, and feathered into the surrounding wave rather than flattened. Drywall nail pops and seams are fixed by resetting or replacing the fastener and finishing the joint.
  • Cracks. Plaster cracks are normal and often run along stress lines or lath edges. Drywall cracks tend to follow taped seams. See our guide on hairline cracks that keep coming back for what reduces the odds that they reopen.
  • Primer. Bare new drywall and fresh patches usually need primer so they absorb paint evenly, and a patch left unprimed often shows as a dull spot, called flashing. Plaster, especially older plaster with many layers of paint, needs cleaning and the right primer for the existing surface. Some fresh plaster and cement-based repairs are alkaline and need time to cure first, while other patches only need to dry fully, so check the label for the wait and the primer.
  • Sheen and finish. Wavy plaster looks better in flat or low-sheen paint. Flat, true drywall can carry more sheen, though higher sheen shows more flaws on any wall.

When both materials meet on one wall, such as a plaster wall with a drywall patch, the patch will usually be flatter and the plaster wavier. A careful painter feathers the joint wide so the transition does not read as a hard edge.

What if you still cannot tell which it is?

Look for a combination of clues. If tapping, raking light and the outlet edge agree, you can be fairly confident; if they disagree, the wall may be one of the lookalikes.

  • Plaster over gypsum-board lath. Also called rock lath, it was in use as early as 1900 and, according to Preservation Brief 21, was used almost exclusively in residential plastering by the late 1930s. It is plaster, but it can feel flatter and more uniform than plaster over wood lath.
  • Skim-coated or veneer-plastered walls. A thin plaster coat over board or old plaster, hard like plaster and flat like drywall.
  • Drywall over plaster. Sometimes added to hide damage. The wall is thicker than expected and can sound dull and solid even though the surface is drywall.
  • Paneling, wallpaper or heavy texture. Anything covering the wall changes how it looks and sounds, so check somewhere uncovered.

At that point, ask a painter or a plasterer to look in person. Our wall and plaster repair page describes the repair side of the work, and our guide to painting plaster walls goes deeper on the finish.

Whatever the material, the paint can only be as smooth and durable as the surface under it, and identifying the wall is the first step of that prep. For the bigger picture, read why prep is the paint job.

Questions

What is the quickest way to tell plaster from drywall?

Tap the wall with a knuckle and look at the wall in low, side light from a flashlight. Plaster sounds dense and solid and looks gently wavy; drywall sounds slightly hollow between studs and may show taped seams. With the circuit switched off at the breaker and confirmed dead with a non-contact voltage tester, the cut edge of the wall around an outlet box shows how thick it is.

Can a house have both plaster and drywall?

Yes, and many older homes do. Original rooms may be plaster while additions, remodeled kitchens and baths, and finished attics and basements are often drywall. Check each wall you plan to paint or repair.

Does the wall type change how it should be painted?

It changes the prep more than the paint. Plaster and drywall use different repair approaches, and fresh patches and bare drywall need primer. Wavy plaster also looks better in flatter sheens, while smooth drywall can take a little more sheen.

Cracks, holes or loose plaster?See how Guiffre’s repairs walls and ceilings so the paint over them looks right.

About the author

Guiffre's Painting Co.

Family-owned interior painting and plaster repair serving Grosse Pointe and Metro Detroit. Owner Bob Guiffre has been painting for more than 37 years — more than 1,800 homes — and his son, Bobby, works beside him on every project. We paint with Sherwin-Williams. Estimates are free. Insured: $1,000,000 general liability. Call (586) 722-3277.

Let’s talk about your home.

Tell us a little about the project and we’ll be in touch to talk it through and set a time to see it. Estimates are free.

Request a free estimate Call